Washington Post and Shoddy Research

 

The Washington Post has published a database of 1700 Congress critters who at one point in their lives owned slaves.  Next they will be doing a dramatic expose on water being wet and fire being hot.  The story is behind a paywall, but one factoid stuck out at me, the claim that 606 slaveholders were Democrats and 481 Republicans.  481 slave holding Republicans?  Sure you would have some who had owned slaves before they saw the light, but 481?  Since almost all Republican members of Congress came from the non-slaveholding North,  I suspect what they have probably done is to lump Jefferson’s Democrat-Republican party in with the anti-slavery Republican party that came into existence in the mid 1850s.  If so, this indicates sloppy research or an attempt to make the slaveholding Democrats not seem so bad if almost as many Republicans were slave holders.  If anyone can shed light on this, let us know in the comboxes.

0 0 votes
Article Rating
13 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Art Deco
Art Deco
Monday, January 10, AD 2022 6:58pm

They also claimed some years back that the Bureau of Justice Statistics was incapable of counting the number of police killing. Don’t hire okupiers.

J. Ronald Parrish
Monday, January 10, AD 2022 7:47pm

It has always seemed ironic to me that we “moderns” are so willing to sit in judgment of people who lived in a different era two hundred years ago when over sixty million preborn babies have been legally slaughtered since 1973. Incidentally, when looking at percent of population, a disproportionate number of those babies have been black.

Foxfier
Admin
Monday, January 10, AD 2022 7:49pm

Poking around for cached copies, the article itself has very little meat. Here’s this:

While the early Republican Party is associated with abolition, The Post found 481 slaveowners who identified as Republicans at some point in their elected careers.

And this:

America’s atrocity was carried out not in shadow, but with extensive documentation, in carefully recorded censuses and court cases and wills. To create this database, The Washington Post researched all of the 5,558 men and one woman, Felton, who served in the U.S. Congress and were born before 1840, meaning they came of age before the Civil War. The verdicts on who enslaved people and who did not are based on journal articles, books, newspapers and many other texts, with the vast majority of the information coming from the 1790 through 1860 decennial censuses.

Which means that they definitely included people who inherited slaves and either freed them or (when that was illegal, because they were elderly) took care of them.

Foxfier
Admin
Monday, January 10, AD 2022 7:50pm

Oh– just realized, that tactic would also include people who used the well-known tactic of buying slaves in order to free them– which is still commonly in use today.

Anzlyne
Anzlyne
Monday, January 10, AD 2022 8:34pm

👍🏻 im too sick and tired to write all the things that could be ssid
Good points well taken previous commentors

CAM
CAM
Monday, January 10, AD 2022 10:18pm

Those numbers are quite possible, considering that of the New England States only Vermont and Massachusetts-Maine had early. laws abolishing slavery and were enforced. Enforcement being a key word. Also indentured for life was oftened used interchangeably with enslaved. Pennsylvania was actually the first to abolish slavery.
New Hampshire formally abolished slavery in 1857 also it seems that the last slave had either died or was manumitted ten years before the law was enacted.
Rhode Island first aboltion law enacted in 1652 was superceded by a legalization of slavery in 1703. Newport was the largest slave market in North America.
New Jersey abolished slavery by an amendment to the state constitution in Jan. 23, 1866.
New York 1830 census listed 75 slaves.
Connecticut by the Revolutinary War had the most slaves in New England. Slav es were given their freedom after they reached 25 years according to a law of 1784.
Several states had Gradual Emancipation laws on the books.
Delaware had 2000 slaves in 1860. In 1901 the state assemble ratified the 13th Amendment 36 years after the rest of the nation.

Clinton
Clinton
Monday, January 10, AD 2022 10:33pm

By the Washington Post’s sloppy standards, the Catholic Church could also be accused of centuries of keeping slaves. After all, Orders like the Knights of St. John, the Templars, and especially the Mercedarians bought them— in bulk.

Of course, what those religious were doing was buying Christians who had been enslaved by Muslims, whether in war or by raiding. The slaves were then brought back home, freed.

By the Post’s dubious research standards, however, the Church was up to Her ears in centuries of slave trading…

Art Deco
Art Deco
Tuesday, January 11, AD 2022 7:54am

Those numbers are quite possible, considering that of the New England States only Vermont and Massachusetts-Maine had early. laws abolishing slavery and were enforced. Enforcement being a key word.

No, they aren’t. The slave population of the northern colonies and states was tiny. And, again, the Republican Party was founded in 1854. The number of man-years logged by Republican members in Congress between the party’s foundation and the abolition of slavery in December 1865 was about 1,155. Even if every member served only two years, you’d still have 578 members, so you’re saying the vast majority of Republicans in Congress during those years were drawn from the north’s tiny slaveholder population. Also, a typical member of Congress ca. 1861 would have been a middle aged man, born ca. 1810. The last slave in New York was manumitted in 1827.

Elisa
Elisa
Tuesday, January 11, AD 2022 9:47am

While the project is a great idea, I don’t “get” what the overall purpose of it is.
Puts on librarian’s cap
For blog readers in the metro DC area, you can register for a free 7 day digital pass from the “Washington Post” through your local public library system. Check if it’s among your library’s e-resources offerings. (Note: If you’re using a public computer and looking at the newspaper listings on the library’s website, you’ll be directed to the Post website from there)

Guy McClung
Guy McClung
Tuesday, January 11, AD 2022 1:26pm

Holding my breath_for the Post’s articles on, and comprehensive lists of 1. Pedophiles in Congress, Senate, Presidency, and Supreme Court, and political icons, activists, leaders; 2. Pederasts in Congress, etc; 3. Adulterers, Congress etc.; 4. Statutory rapists, Congress, etc.; 5. Philanderers, Congress, etc.; 6. Rapists [of all persuasions and inclinations], Congress, etc. Guy, Texas

Elaine Biggerstaff
Elaine Biggerstaff
Tuesday, January 11, AD 2022 1:57pm

If the Washington Post was anything but a promoter and purveyor of the lies of the Devil, they would post the millions upon millions of both white and black slaveholders as slavery was as normal as breathing for all of recorded history until the moral principles of Christianity finally got through to the masses and rulers and was the real cause of the end of slavery.

We know they will never tell this truth so who cares what they say?

CAM
CAM
Tuesday, January 11, AD 2022 3:04pm

Which Republican Party is the Post article referencing?
The National Republican Party, also known as the Anti-Jacksonian Party or simply Republicans, was a political party in the United States that evolved from a faction of the Democratic-Republican Party that supported John Quincy Adams in the 1824 presidential election. The National Republican Party was dissolved in 1834.
The Democratic-Republican Party, also referred to as the Jeffersonian Republican Party and known at the time under various other names,[a] was an American political party founded by Thomas Jefferson and James Madison in the early 1790s that championed republicanism, agrarianism, political equality, and expansionism. The party became increasingly dominant after the 1800 elections as the opposing Federalist Party collapsed. The Democratic-Republicans later splintered during the 1824 presidential election. The majority faction of the Democratic-Republicans eventually coalesced into the modern Democratic Party, while the minority faction ultimately formed the core of what became the Whig Party.

Art Deco
Art Deco
Tuesday, January 11, AD 2022 5:13pm

Which Republican Party is the Post article referencing?

Jefferson’s outfit was the Republican Party, which fell apart into regional factions in 1824. The terms ‘Democratic-Republican’ and ‘National Republican’ emerged in 1828 as monikers for factions which emerged. The terms were only in use for a half-dozen years or so. Many history books anachronistically refer to Jefferson’s outfit as ‘Democratic-Republican’ to distinguish it from the 1854 foundation. This generates confusion.

Scroll to Top