Thought For The Day

As Boccacio noted seven centuries ago:

 

The Jew mounted his horse, and as quickly as possible went to the court of Rome, where arriving, he was by his fellow Jews honorably received; and living there without saying to anybody why he came, began cautiously to study the manners of the Pope and the cardinals and the prelates and all the other courtesans; and he learned, being the honest man that he was, and being informed by other people, that from the greatest to the lowest they sinned most dishonestly, not only in natural but in unnatural ways, without any restraint or remorse to shame them; so much so that for the poor and the dissolute of both sexes to take part in any affair was no small thing. Besides this he saw that they were universally gluttons, wine-drinkers, and drunkards, and much devoted to their stomachs after the manner of brute animals; given up to luxury more than to anything else. And looking further, he saw that they were in the same manner all avaricious and desirous of money, so that human blood, even that of Christians, and sacred interests, whatever they might be, even pertaining to the ceremonies or to the benefices, were sold and bought with money; making a greater merchandise out of these things and having more shops for them than at Paris of stuffs or any other things, and to the most open simony giving the name and support of procuration, and to gluttony that of sustentation: as if God, apart from the signification of epithets, could not know the intentions of these wretched souls, but after the manner of men must permit himself to be deceived by the names of things. Which, together with many other things of which we will say nothing, so greatly displeased the Jew, that as he was a sober and modest man it appeared to him that he had seen enough, and proposed to return to Paris.

Accordingly he did so; upon which Gianotto, seeing that he had returned, and hoping nothing less than that he should have become a Christian, came and rejoiced greatly at his return, and after some days of rest asked him what he thought of the Holy Father, the cardinals, and the other courtesans; to which the Jew promptly replied:—“It seems to me evil that God should have given anything to all those people, and I say to you that if I know how to draw conclusions, there was no holiness, no devotion, no good work or good example of life in any other way, in anybody who was a priest; but luxury, avarice, and gluttony,—such things and worse, if there could be worse things in anybody; and I saw rather liberty in devilish operations than in divine: on which account I conclude that with all possible study, with all their talent and with all their art, your Shepherd, and consequently all the rest, are working to reduce to nothing and to drive out of the world the Christian religion, there where they ought to be its foundation and support. But from what I see, what they are driving at does not happen, but your religion continually increases; and therefore it becomes clearer and more evident that the Holy Spirit must be its foundation and support, as a religion more true and holy than any other. On which account, where I was obstinate and immovable to your reasoning and did not care to become a Christian, now I say to you distinctly that on no account would I fail to become a Christian. Therefore let us go to church, and there according to the custom of your holy religion let me be baptized.

 

5 1 vote
Article Rating
6 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
The Bruised Optimist
The Bruised Optimist
Wednesday, February 12, AD 2025 7:35am

It seems to me evil that God should have given anything to all those people…

Strikes to the marrow!

When I came into the Church, it was with the understanding that there were bad Catholics, but I understood that their badness had no impact on the Truth.

I must admit, though, that I did not expect so many of them to have been ordained 💔

CAG
CAG
Wednesday, February 12, AD 2025 7:39am

Belloc I get, but couldn’t the Jewish convert’s argument also be used to justify Islam?

Frank
Frank
Wednesday, February 12, AD 2025 7:59am

CAG, good question, but I don’t think the analogy holds, because I would wager that the vast majority of “conversions” to Islam are coerced.

Josh
Josh
Wednesday, February 12, AD 2025 11:39am

Indeed, Islam is deterministic to the core.

trackback
Thursday, February 13, AD 2025 9:21am

[…] Mentioned News Stories on Big Pulpit:Thought For The Day – Donald R. McClarey, J.D., at The American CatholicPope’s Stance On Immigration Sparks […]

Scroll to Top