Go here to read the article.
Although Pope Leo XIV had initially informed the Cardinals that four topics would be taken up, upon their arrival at the consistory the members of the Sacred College were told that, owing to time constraints, they would be asked to select only two. They chose “the Synod and Synodality” and the mission of the Church in light of Pope Francis’s 2013 apostolic exhortation on the proclamation of the Gospel, Evangelii Gaudium.
At its core, the intervention argues that the synodal process was not merely flawed but tightly managed in a way that deprived bishops of genuine deliberative freedom and of their rightful authority as successors of the apostles. Cardinal Zen also sharply denounced what he sees as the instrumental use of spiritual language, warning that constant appeals to the Holy Spirit are being deployed to sanctify predetermined outcomes, as if the Spirit could be expected to contradict the Church’s two-thousand-year Tradition.
The intervention then broadens its warning to the wider Church. By assigning the Final Document a paradoxical status—magisterial yet “not strictly normative,” authoritative yet open to divergent local interpretations—the process risks doctrinal incoherence and ecclesial fragmentation. The cardinal cautions that this approach mirrors the path that led to division within Anglicanism and undermines Catholic credibility in ecumenical dialogue, particularly with the Orthodox Churches, for whom synodality has always meant the real authority of bishops acting together and walking together with Jesus Christ.
Zen knows a con game when he sees one. Synod has been stripped of its meaning and used as a tool to replace Catholicism with trendy Leftism. That was the goal of Pope Francis. I hope that Pope Leo will not follow him on that downward path.
At the present time, P. Leo increasingly appears to be channeling Paul VI—too weak to set out to unify the Church by reaffirming Catholic tradition, and too committed to affirming the divisive Curial mistakes and wanderings of the previous pontificate.
I know it’s absurd… but Leo was selected by Francis (& company) to continue Francis’ Reign.
Leo simply needs to realize that totally insane falsity.
I really really don’t like what I have seen in Leo’s eyes (“oh no, oh no..”) when he’s holding the Monstrance for Adoration. I don’t think he believes IT.
David WS, I know what you mean; on the other hand, maybe he does believe IT, and he’s looking at his Lord with trepidation over what he is perpetuating from the See of Peter.
Just a thought.
Cardinal Zen is a treasure to the Church, too bad he’s been marginalized by leadership. He’s very inconvenient, these ideas, not with the zeitgeist. The Cardinal is not hip enough to understand today’s world, too old fashioned.
Good for Cardinal Zen saying it out loud.
We could use more cardinals without any sense of self preservation!
Well, the previous Pope wouldn’t even meet with Cardinal Zen, so there’s that …