LeoWatch: Harmless Heresy?

When everyone is considered to be a Christian, no one is a Christian.  Some Catholic thinkers, like Hilaire Belloc, regarded Islam as a Christian heresy, and more to be condemned as a result.  I regard it as an alien faith, dressed up with rags and tags that Mohammed obtained from various sources, many of them Christian heretics.  Almost all Muslims would reject as nonsense that they are in any sense Christian, and I agree with them.  I doubt if this Kraut priest will experience any papal correction.  It isn’t as if he did something seriously heretical in the eyes of the Vatican, like defending the traditional Mass, condemning the Vatican-China deal or saying that Rupnik still has powerful protectors at the Vatican.  Priorities, priorities.

5 3 votes
Article Rating
13 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Josh
Josh
Thursday, September 24, AD 2026 4:35am

Reading this, all I can be reminded of is the “Yes, Prime Minister” episode where Hacker needs to recommend a bishop in the C of E, and the man ultimately appointed (the Dean of Sir Humphrey’s alma mater) is constantly referenced as one who believes Christianity and Islam are equivalent (as well as loving cricket and steam engines).

The catch then was no one took the Dean seriously, and the episode is a hoot of puns, but the kind of nonsense coming from this guy is no laughing matter.

And nothing will be done, as Don rightly points out.

Dave G.
Dave G.
Thursday, September 24, AD 2026 5:22am

If he means Byzantine as Orthodox Christianity, he might want to talk to some Byzantine Christians about that. During my time with our Orthodox brethren, I heard more than once them refer to Islam as a Christian heresy (but then they say the same thing about Western Christianity as well). I also learned that Orthodoxy is not just Catholicism without a pope. It is a world apart. In many cases, as Dracula would say, their ways are not our ways. And they see almost everything (that includes Israel and the Middle East) through a different set of glasses than we in the West.

CAG
CAG
Thursday, September 24, AD 2026 7:59am

Last I checked, the Byzantines believe (and have always believed) that Jesus Christ is the son of God, the second Person of the holy Trinity who died for our sins, rose from the dead, ascended into Heaven and is seated at the right hand of God the Father. 

Byzantines also believe The Eucharist is the Body and Blood of our Lord.

The muslims don’t believe any of those things.

Really, I think the only thing in our entire Creed that they do believe would be “Born of the Virgin Mary”.

Elaine Krewer
Admin
Thursday, September 24, AD 2026 8:08am

Another figure who, apparently, considered Islam to be a Christian heresy was Dante Aligheri, who placed Mohammed and his son-in-law Ali in a circle of the Inferno reserved for “sowers of discord”, i.e., those who instigated wars, heresies, family feuds and other conflicts. Their punishment was to walk endlessly in a circle being hacked apart by demons with swords. Dante used particularly colorful language to describe how Mohammed was literally split down the middle from his neck to his, shall we say, nether regions….

CAG
CAG
Thursday, September 24, AD 2026 8:32am

[Adding The Inferno to Autumn reading list now …] 🙂

The Bruised Optimist
The Bruised Optimist
Thursday, September 24, AD 2026 9:26am

Aslan is Tash. Tash is Aslan. Tashlan.

I just pray that all these super-smarties wise up during their FA stage, before their final moment of FO.

Thanks be to God that I did. (His work, not mine. I’m certainly not more clever than those days. He has just given me the gift of seeing more clearly.)

David WS
David WS
Thursday, September 24, AD 2026 10:40am

Islam is obviously an ape of Judaism & Christianity…. mostly Christianity. the synodal band plays on…

IMG_0570
David WS
David WS
Thursday, September 24, AD 2026 2:36pm

apologies.. i find it necessary to maintain a sense of humor.

Steve Phoenix
Steve Phoenix
Thursday, September 24, AD 2026 4:35pm

Echoing CAG, does Fr. Wintzek not realize Muslims believe the Trinity is heresy (“God is one: I bear witness that there is no god but Allah and I bear witness that Muhammad is his prophet..”, the oath called the Shahada, the primary pillar of Islam: first of the 5 pillars of Islam)?

Greg Mockeridge
Greg Mockeridge
Friday, September 25, AD 2026 12:13am

Technically, for something to be heresy, it has to claim Christian pedigree. Islam doesn’t. But because Islam takes a great deal from heretical Christianity, it is regarded as a Christian heresy, practically speaking. It seems to me what that’s what Belloc meant.

Now, I wouldn’t think it would be wise for the pope to call out Islam for the bloodthirsty political system masquerading as a religion that it is for what should be obvious reasons. But he shouldn’t pander to Islam neither.

Mary De Voe
Friday, September 25, AD 2026 1:21am

In Germany, the state collects the tithes and then gives the collection to the church. It may seem as though the state supports the church, but that is not so.
Germany has a special place in Vatican II since it was Karl
Rahner who hijacked Vatican II and ruined everything.
Allah has no son to love or to love him. Does Allah know how to love?
Since God is Love and Allah does not love, how can Islam be a religion?

CATHERINE MASAK
CATHERINE MASAK
Friday, September 25, AD 2026 7:49am

I THINK THIS MAN IS ON DRUGS

Scroll to Top