When You Go Home, Tell Them Of Us And Say, For Your Tomorrow, We Gave Our Today
 Inscription on the memorial to the dead of the British 2nd Infantry Division at Kohima.
War is an ugly thing, but not the ugliest of things: the decayed and degraded state of moral and patriotic feeling which thinks that nothing is worth a war, is much worse. When a people are used as mere human instruments for firing cannon or thrusting bayonets, in the service and for the selfish purposes of a master, such war degrades a people. A war to protect other human beings against tyrannical injustice; a war to give victory to their own ideas of right and good, and which is their own war, carried on for an honest purpose by their free choice, — is often the means of their regeneration. A man who has nothing which he is willing to fight for, nothing which he cares more about than he does about his personal safety, is a miserable creature who has no chance of being free, unless made and kept so by the exertions of better men than himself. As long as justice and injustice have not terminated their ever-renewing fight for ascendancy in the affairs of mankind, human beings must be willing, when need is, to do battle for the one against the other.
John Stuart Mill, 1862
One of my earliest memories is being called a “Dirty Yank”. My Dad met my Mom while he was in the Air Force in Newfoundland. After his enlistment ended he was unable to find work in Saint John’s, my Mom’s home town, so the young couple traveled to my Dad’s home town in Paris, Illinois. I made my appearance shortly thereafter. My Mom, who was all of 21 at the time, grew homesick, so she and my Dad, an elderly 24, pulled up stakes again and moved back to Saint John’s. Family tranquility was forever destroyed when my little brother arrived a year and a half later, as he and I quickly put our heads together for campaigns of mischief and nefarious activities which enlivened my childhood. The family stayed in Saint John’s until I was four, jobs were still scarce on the ground there, alas, before the family moved back permanently to Paris in the summer of 1961.
During our stay in Saint John’s I met all of my maternal relatives on a frequent basis, and other than my maternal Grandmother and Grandfather, my favorite was no doubt my great Uncle Bill Barry. Whenever he would come over he would yell out, “There’s that Dirty Yank!” I would lisp out in return, “There’s that Dirty Newf”!
Bill Barry was a truly wonderful man. An Irishman with a laughing, sunny disposition, he was also a fighter. A boxer in his young manhood, he lived up to Chesterton’s famous observation about the inhabitants of the Emerald Isle:
 For the great Gaels of IrelandÂ
 Are the men that God made mad,
For all their wars are merry,
And all their songs are sad.
He loved to brawl when he was a young man, but there was always a smile on his face when he was doing so, albeit the police who had to bust up some of the fights he got involved in didn’t always share the joke. It was to be expected that such a man would join up with the British Army immediately after war was declared on Germany in 1939. When he was asked why he did, he said, “Well, someone has to teach the Limies how to fight!” Fight he did, taking part in the D-Day invasion, and fighting on through France, Belgium, the Netherlands and Germany until the thousand year Reich became the twelve year Reich. He rose from private to sergeant, receiving a field promotion for the courage and leadership he displayed in taking a village. He had a short spell as a noncom. After the Lieutenant left him and a squad in charge of the village, Uncle Bill led his men to an abandoned wine cellar and then, as all the best military leaders do, led by example. “Men, do as I do!” he shouted as he began to chug a bottle of wine. Inspired by this oration his men followed him, and by the time the Lieutenant arrived back, Uncle Bill and his command were dancing in the streets. The Lieutenant promptly, and correctly, tore the stripes off Uncle Bill’s tunic and he spent the rest of the war as a private. That was fine with Uncle Bill, since he had signed up to fight and not to make the Army a career. A fighter Uncle Bill definitely was, but not a soldier!
His family rejoiced when he arrived back in Newfoundland in one piece, my future Mom noting that he seemed just the same, although he was now sensitive to loud noises. However, one night my Mom saw that the War had left a deeper mark on Uncle Bill. She was visiting Uncle Bill and his wife Aunt Nool, and an older couple came over to see Uncle Bill.  Their son had served with Uncle Bill and had been killed in the War. Uncle Bill talked with them and told them how much all the other men in his unit had liked their boy, and how he had been very brave. After he died they had buried him with full military honors. This all seemed to be of great comfort to the older couple, and they thanked Uncle Bill and left. My Mom then saw something she had never seen before, her tough and always smiling Uncle Bill weeping. He turned to Aunt Nool and said that he hadn’t realized that he was such a good liar. The poor son of the older couple had stepped upon a huge land mine and there hadn’t been enough left of him to bury.
I think of that young soldier on this Veterans Day and of Uncle Bill. Veterans Day is all about memory. We remember our veterans and we say thank you. Gratitude is one of the noblest of human sentiments, just as ingratitude is one of the lowest. Those who died in war are far beyond, as Lincoln put it, “our poor power to add or detract”, but it is important for us to remember them and their comrades who survived their war but still bore the scars of conflict.  We remember their sacrifice and honor that sacrifice. We comfort, as best we can, those they have left behind. We build monuments to them that many of them never see in the flesh, make speeches about them that many of them can never hear in the flesh, and write words about them that many of them can never read in the flesh, but all of these aid in our ability to remember them. Courage and love are always in short supply in this vale of tears, and on Veterans Day we remember, and honor, both.  Our thanks and gratitude to the fallen, and to those who survived their service, and our determination to remember them, is small tribute enough, but it is the best that we have. Let us live our lives in honor and decency, doing good for those around us, and thus be worthy of the great sacrifice they made. May God grant them His mercy, and may we recall those who have passed on, not just on Veterans Day, but every day.
Thank you very much for sharing that story of Uncle Bill.
May God grant eternal rest to his soul.
Thank you Cathy. He was an unforgettable character.
Both my grandfathers served overseas with the Canadian Expeditionary Force in WWI. My Irish Canadian paternal grandfather, who fought at Vimy Ridge and Passchendaele had a similar experience. Private to sergeant and back to private due to a party in which they apparently got carried away and damaged their rifles (a big no no). From his records he lasted a year as we know he lasted a year as a sergeant. He was the heavyweight boxing champion of the Canadian Army. A coal miner, he survived the war.
My father served as a sergeant air gunner in the Royal Canadian Air Force in WWII. I grew up as an air force brat after the war and served. I did not fight in any wars. Per ardua ad astra.
John the Mad, Major (Ret’d)
I meant (hit the post button accidentally. I meant to salute American veterans and military personnel. Every”Dirty Yank” I ever met in the military were great folks to know, friendly and a credit to the profession of arms. Bravo zulu!
Bravo John, a salute to our brave Canadian allies!
I didn’t get to meet up with…well, anybody but a few Republic of Korea guys, in passing, when I was in– but the guys I talked to who did get to hang out with the Canadians all mentioned how blessed much they DID with such little support. (And for some of those guys, that’s incredible praise!)
Bravo John, a salute to our brave Canadian allies!
Pierre Elliot Trudeau begged off any kind of military service during the war (something that would have been hardly possible in the States). His opposite number Robert Stanfield also had no time in the service.
We still have my parents’ house and I found a boxes of letters to my dad from his family when he was in pre overseas training and then in England. The letters were from his parents, three other brothers in training and his older sister and her husband . I learned of Aunt Izzy’s and Uncle Gordy’s sorrow in their losing a baby boy (after many tries they never did have any living children) and how my dad’s thoughtful Christmas gifts were a bright spot in their grief. My grandmother thanking my dad for his allotment used to heat their house over the cold New England winter. My grandfather giving dad father son advice. Uncle Bill finishing West Point and off to flight training. Uncle Dick hoping he and dad could rally on leave from their respective camps. Aunt Izzy advising my dad on knowing when to pop the question to his girl friend (not my mom). Izzy anxious to meet his sweetheart because ” you’re such a great guy, Larry, she must be a terrific gal.”
Pretty much day to day life expressed in the letters but all letters were full of love. I haven’t gotten to the other boxes when dad was overseas. Somewhere there are letters between my husband and me when he was at sea thirty – forty years ago.
I wonder if anyone writes letters anymore? Somehow texts and emails just aren’t the same.
On the Tucker Carlson show tonight did anyone notice Canadian Mark Steyne ‘s poppy in his suit coat lapel? There’s a jar full of paper poppies at the feed and seed store…in Flanders fields where poppies grow…do they teach post WWI poetry in school anymore?
Happy Veterans’ Day!
I wasn’t out and about too much these past few days, but I was at a grocery store for a quick stop this weekend. I always used to see a table with at least one old vet from the local VFW or American Legion selling those paper poppies. Not this year or last. My husband always made a point to stop if we saw them and “buy” (donate for) some poppies. His dad served in Korea during that war, and is still with us at age 92.
My daughter did a short presentation on “In Flanders Fields” for 4H several years ago, and I think I can still recite most of the poem after hearing her practice. It is a very moving poem, esp. when you know the story behind it.
Thank you, Cam, for sharing those family stories.
I’ve been trying to write some cards and letters to friends and family, more so earlier this year when I was more housebound. With the summer, this little bird was more free from her cage, but now with autumn and more intended “shutdowns” already happening (just in time for the holidays!) I will try to write more again. Email is nice to keep in touch, but I’ve found that getting something personal and handwritten means a lot.
There’s a jar full of paper poppies at the feed and seed store…in Flanders fields where poppies grow…do they teach post WWI poetry in school anymore?
I grew up in a place where you could get the VFW poppy each year, and even they didn’t quote it.
…I just realized that most of the folks I interacted with then were Vietnam and Korea, and they looked at the WWI and WWII guys like I from Enduring Freedom look at the Vietnam and Korea guys.
I’m scared for when we lose them.
The poems didn’t get taught because they’re HARD. Painful, and wonderful, but hard. And there’s no easy “hate this person, this group is bad” option. WWI doesn’t even make any sense.
FYI. The first three seasons of a show called Son of a Critch is on Netflix. It is set in Newfoundland and is very much like a Catholic version of The Goldbergs. I enjoyed it.
Thanks George! I will have to look at it!
Uncle Bill sounds amazing. Thank you for sharing this.
He was always a lot of fun to be around. Some people seem born just to put a smile on the faces of those around them, and he was among that select company.
Fantastic, touching, and well deserving tribute, Don. Thank you.
Thanks Dan. Many people have been teachers for me in my life, and Uncle Bill was among my first and most loved.