Saturday, April 20, AD 2024 12:41am

The Wrong War With the Wrong Country at the Wrong Time

 

It has been bleakly amusing to see Leftists suddenly become war hawks.  The Clinton concocted face saving myth that she lost the 2016 election because of Russian collusion with the Trump campaign has hardened into anti-Russian hysteria with Leftists calling their opponents traitors in league with Putin.  The funny thing about fits of national hysteria is that the manufacturers of the hysteria often lose control of it and it ends in national disaster.  So it is with the eagerness of Leftists to fly to the defense of the Ukraine.  A few thoughts before the first casualties:

  1. I doubt there will be US involvement if Putin does invade.  The Puppetmasters are all talk.  Absent economic sanctions, nothing will be done.  The premature bug out of our diplomatic staff shows that Afghanistan is the model.  However, events can be unpredictable and wars develop a logic all their own once shooting begins.
  2. Our deeply demoralized woke military is a paper tiger and likely incapable of carrying out a ground war in Ukraine, at least a ground war we could win.
  3. Nato is an organization well beyond its sell by date and is no longer useful for this country.
  4. We have no vital interests in Ukraine, especially while confronting a rising Chinese threat in the Pacific which is the major US foreign interest.
  5. Russia is a third world nation in many ways masquerading as a superpower.  Becoming involved militarily against it near its borders is the only way it can hurt this nation, short of it hoping that its aging nuclear missiles do not explode on the ground if they attempted to launch them against us.
  6. Putin is a tyrant and an all around bad guy and I would hate to live in Russia, but in this vale of tears we have to choose our enemies as wisely as we choose our friends.
  7. Isolationism is not a realistic policy and it is becoming too popular on the right.
  8. With Biden we have a commander in chief clearly suffering from dementia and shadowy forces making the decisions instead of an elected President.
  9. This nation hasn’t waged war against a power like Russia since 1945.  A nation that tired of fighting the Taliban simply doesn’t have the stomach for such a fight.
  10.  Wars not infrequently begin because of a long chain of mistaken assumptions.  In regard to our policy as to Ukraine and Russia, those mistaken assumptions are radically on display.  The US has never really intended to fight to keep the Ukraine free from the designs of a resurgent Russia.  Pretending otherwise has been an exercise in writing checks on a bank account with insufficient funds and expecting the funds to magically appear in the account.   The idea that Nato, or rather now the shadow of the old Nato, was a prop to maintain Ukrainian independence was always a fantasy.
  11. Putin is not a recreation of Hitler but rather of Mussolini, and China is using him to distract us from responding to their next moves.
  12. It is said with considerable truth that generals always fight the last war.  Diplomats, on the other hand, are always attempting to recreate a world in balance that never was.
0 0 votes
Article Rating
12 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
T. Shaw
T. Shaw
Wednesday, January 26, AD 2022 8:23am

LQC: US so-called elites are doing everything to advance that.

The CCP-owned stooges called Trump’s tariffs on China trade crimes, “The Trump Trade War.” Like the global terror war against the Free World [free 9/11/2001], China’s trade war with the USA has been flagrant for decades. It’s just that the globalist stooges [making billions on China’s ascendancy and America’s ruin] and bought-and-paid-for academics and media – including the Bush wing of the RINO party – are totally ‘on board with it.’

In addition, even money after the Chinese Olympics, Taiwan will be conquered.

They [Putin and Xi] have to be convinced [See Afghanistan debacle] that China Joe, Ron Klain, Susan Rice or whoever operates the CCP-controlled junta are no obstacle.

Foxfier
Admin
Wednesday, January 26, AD 2022 8:38am

I’m sure that the congressman is getting callers who say they’re conservatives– probably “life-long conservatives”– and that Russia should rightfully be given every single country that escaped the USSR and has recovered in any way.

The same guys have shown up most places that I visit that have open comments… with one exception, the place that blocked all Russia ISPs.

Almost like Russia has a large supply of paid trolls who are great with fighting the Dems, but don’t want anyone to think in terms of “Russia has been scared to death that Ukraine would join NATO before they can finish looting the place.”

Bob Kurland
Admin
Wednesday, January 26, AD 2022 10:18am

Is this a “Tail that wagged the dog:” so we turn our attention away from Biden’s woeful performance?

Art Deco
Art Deco
Wednesday, January 26, AD 2022 10:36am

In re production and real income, Russia has a second-tier economy. Life expectancy there is depressed by about five years in comparison to other affluent countries. Compared to the mode in Europe, it has elevated crime rates as well. It’s not currently suffering from acute macroeconomic problems. However subpar it is on static measures, it has experienced dramatic improvement in its condition for over 20 years.

Putin runs a machine boss regime. Dmitri Simes referred to it as ‘managed pluralism’. It’s far more benevolent than the pre-1985 Soviet regime. There are political alternatives to Putin, but the most liberal democratic among them just do not have much of a public constituency.

What we’re seeing now is that the regime harbors (and promotes in its populace) revanchist sentiments that could be very injurious to a raft of parties. Same deal with China. I’m not liking where this is going. (Americans inclined to act as press agents for Putin are repulsive).

Art Deco
Art Deco
Wednesday, January 26, AD 2022 10:40am

I think Greenwald is wrong in this instance. Frum’s critique of the Rockford Institute and it’s associates was fair; that’s why they’re all still butt-hurt about it.

Donald Link
Wednesday, January 26, AD 2022 10:49am

My late German grandmother was correct. Russians are barbarians and their uncivilized manners in stirring around Europe since 1914 are the cause of most of today’s mess. War is certainly neither necessary nor desirable though it might help in the interests of solidarity if Germany would grow a pair. No thinking country would offshore 40% of their energy supply to Russia. One wonders if Europe is even worth saving with their short sighted pettiness and bureaucratic bumbling.

Lucius Quinctius Cincinnatus
Wednesday, January 26, AD 2022 1:03pm

@Donald Link:

Germany has de-nuked itself and its wind and solar don’t work, so it has to rely on Russian methane.

https://www.wsj.com/articles/germanys-reliance-on-russian-gas-limits-europes-options-in-ukraine-crisis-11642939203

Ezabelle
Ezabelle
Wednesday, January 26, AD 2022 5:06pm

Ukraine is just the first in Putin’s aim to rebuilt a former USSR.

https://www.foxnews.com/opinion/putin-soviet-union-ukraine-rep-michael-waltz

Lucius Quinctius Cincinnatus
Wednesday, January 26, AD 2022 5:58pm

Ezabelle is rite.

We aren’t ready for Russia & China. I just watched Sub Brief on YouTube. We’re in the deep dark $h1t$.

https://youtu.be/4YHjEqPxb_I

Discover more from The American Catholic

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading

Scroll to Top