For the fifth Sunday in a row, the Lord’s Prayer at our Church’s Mass was sung, a version put out by the Notre Dame Folk Choir. This cranky old physicist (with pretensions to musical and liturgical taste) finds the melody banal, the whole song elevator music for liturgists, and offputting from focused prayer. I will dispute the argument that this is the sort of stuff that’s needed to bring young people into the Church.
The ICEL chant has beauty, dignity and supports a prayerful disposition.
And then of course there’s always the old standby, just praying the “Our Father”.
Maybe I am out of touch with what the modern liturgy should be, and should find a time machine to go back 60 years or so ago. Let’s do a poll (even though the sampling for readers of this blog is not going to be unbiased). Please comment on which version of the Lord’s Prayer you would prefer at Mass: