LeoWatch: Predictable Pontiff
- Donald R. McClarey
Donald R. McClarey
Cradle Catholic. Active in the pro-life movement since 1973. Father of three, one in Heaven, and happily married for 43 years. Small town lawyer and amateur historian. Former president of the board of directors of the local crisis pregnancy center for a decade.
Assessing the conduct of Cdl Law and others over the period running from 1982 to 2001, one wag said that it appeared what the bishops actually believed in was…psychiatry.
==
There are in this country 575,000 counselors, 70,000 clinical psychologists, and 25,000 psychiatrists. They manage to earn a living at it. What share of their ‘clients’ actually benefit from their ‘services’ is another matter. How many could make rent from what they do absent 3d party payments and government salaries is amusing to contemplate. What share of them has a categorical objection to genital mutilation and hormone ‘treatments’ done for no other reason than to please sexual fetishists (and financed with 3d party payments, natch) would be interesting to know. Of course, in this day and age, some of the objections remain unstated due to abuse and intimidation by hospital administrators.
==
Oh, and they’re doing a bang up job reducing the population on skid row.
I love the idea that there is stigma about mental health, as if we’re living in the 1800s. Almost everything is mental health today. And it’s worth noting that the more we pour into mental health, the worse our mental health seems to be getting. Yet the solution is always invest more. We put a billion into it and it’s worse than ever, so let’s put two billion into it, that should do the trick.
No repair unless the client-patient co-operates. Carl Jung says that the Catholic Church with its Sacraments is the best cure. It is Jesus Christ Son of God Who cures. Pope Bob needs to realize and accept the Truth about Jesus Christ raising the dead and curing the sick.
No repair unless the client-patient co-operates. Carl Jung says that the Catholic Church with its Sacraments is the best.
My father was a psychiatrist and Chief of Staff of a Catholic Mental Health Hospital. This was long before the country began to celebrate lgbtq Etc. A significant part of his practice was counseling that true happiness comes only through Christ. He told me about a gay patient where his advice was that he would have to stop his lifestyle to heal his mental issues. The patient said he would just change psychiatrists until he found one that agreed with him. Knowing my dad I’m sure that he stayed consistent that Christ is the physician. After he passed away, for many years I found anonymous notes on his grave from patients that thanked him and missed him.
For many progressives, this papal flatulation seems rather self-serving.
The greatest fear in finding mental help is knowing that the profession officially approves of LGB etc. How do you send your child for “help” when the helper is likely to recommend one of the following:
Explore your extramarital, immoral, or perverse sexuality.
Question whether God exists.
Discard your judgemental parents.
Take drugs that can cause suicidal thoughts.
There is almost no way to know which counseling can be trusted not to do these detrimental things. A ministry from today’s hierarchy is not *at all* helpful. The hierarchy have shown themselves to be inept at keeping Catholic colleges even basically Catholic. (They are often antagonistic to the faith.) The hierarchy also has shown a willingness to hide malefactors like Rupnik. Does *anybody* really think they’re going to defend, let alone encourage, a counselor who opposed the establishment on atheism, LGB, or trans?
More useless $h!t from the bishops office and USCCB and Vatican that siphons off money that should be used to keep St Local Church open.
Lead Kindly Light:
Your comment is beautiful.
Q: How many psychiatrists does it take to change a lightbulb?
A: The psychiatrist can’t change a lightbulb unless first the lightbulb wants to change
🙂
It’s all about replacing sin with mental health issues. And it’s BS. Yes, there are mental health issues. But the overwhelming majority of aberrant and depraved behavior is because of sin. I doubt this Pope recognizes anything as sinful except being a traditionalist Catholic like SSPX or a conservative patriotic Christian.
1971 indeed, so predictable.
Ok, I just read an article by Damian Thompson that mentioned something unpredictable (at least to me) about Pope Leo. The Pope went into Paris, the capital of a country which has a constitutional right to abortion, spoke forcefully against their anti-life policies, and then offered Mass with six downs syndrome altar servers.
… Francis didn’t even offer public Mass.
“In his mind it is always 1971..”
That recent? Not 1966, “A new Springtime in the Church…”
Blessed Archbishop Sheen said that kneeling to confess one’s sins would do more good for the soul than lying on a couch to confess them. He was not anti-psychiatry but differentiated between the sickness of the soul and the sickness of the mind. They are related but that is not to say that there are not legitimate psychoses, like schizophrenia, that need medical intervention.
They are on full display at your local subway station- no shame in them at all….not even when they stab a Ukrainian girl in the neck
Well, my life experience is that mental health problems are real. I have had to live with them for years. My wife has a number of OCDs. Each one is small but add them up and they are aggravating. Hoarding. A constant appetite for bad news all over the world and then crying obsessively about it. Locking every door when I go outside to wash a car, mow the yard or any other outside work. She believes every word that comes from my older son’s mouth. There is at least one other that I won’t name.
My older son is neck deep in ADHD. He has body dysmorphic disorder and if you think this is a joke try being woke up at 2 AM to hear profanity laced screaming about teeth, hair, or a jaw that isn’t “masculine” enough. Oppositional defiant disorder…something that could have been cured with a good belt whipping or two years ago, but now some so called professionals call that child abuse.
Paranoia, extreme envy…all this and others wear on a person. My youngest son often just goes to his room and shuts the door in an attempt to keep it all out of his life.
When my older son was told no before he turned 18 the response was that I abused him and he would report me for it. He ruined a group camping trip with my younger son’s FNE troop. Now when he is told no he threatens other stupid things.
One of the worst things that have come from all of this is that it brought back bad memories of my dad. My dad throwing me on the floor and beating me with a belt because I fell on my brother playing in the yard and he had a cut on his head. My dad blaming me for fights between my brothers and some neighbor kids I had nothing to do with and cracking me in the face when I said I had nothing to do with it. Or, when I tried to stand up for myself in school and getting in trouble…I got it worse at home.
I could go on but I’ll stop about that herem
When I hear or read something from a priest about suffering…and to be grateful for it, I get resentful anymore and I don’t want to hear it. I am not grateful for what has happened to me.
Look…I consider the mental health “industry” has created a lot of demand for itself. That doesn’t change the fact that there are some really messed up people for which Confession isn’t going to help.
Penguins Fan-
Yes, the mental health is off a cliff compared to previous times.
Since human beings do not change, it must be environmental.
The crucial question is whether it is the physical environment or the spiritual environment. I honestly don’t know.
I would not be surprised to discover that many things which have been sold to us as physical progress are mentally damaging. Of course, the current spiritual & moral chaos does not help mental health either.
That doesn’t change the fact that there are some really messed up people for which Confession isn’t going to help.
==
As always, the question is what the mental health trade actually accomplish. They have a menu of excuses, of course.