Few issues more starkly show the chasm between the traditional Catholic Church and whatever we have now than the death penalty. The idea that morality is determined by citing the calendar would have struck almost all Catholic thinkers prior to 1950 as bizarre at best, heretical at worst. The late Cardinal Dulles, in 2001, wrote an article in First Things, go here to read it, in which he stated:
The Catholic magisterium does not, and never has, advocated unqualified abolition of the death penalty. I know of no official statement from popes or bishops, whether in the past or in the present, that denies the right of the State to execute offenders at least in certain extreme cases. The United States bishops, in their majority statement on capital punishment, conceded that “Catholic teaching has accepted the principle that the State has the right to take the life of a person guilty of an extremely serious crime.” Joseph Cardinal Bernardin, in his famous speech on the “Consistent Ethic of Life” at Fordham in 1983, stated his concurrence with the “classical position” that the State has the right to inflict capital punishment.
I don’t think that is any longer correct. Pope Francis stated that the death penalty is always inadmissible. Pope Francis was attempting to change the magisterium of the the Church by using the weasel word “inadmissible”. How a Pope can condemn what God in Scripture sanctions I will leave to wits wiser, or more sophistical, than mine.
“Few issues more starkly show the chasm between the traditional Catholic Church and whatever we have now than the death penalty. “
the point was never the death penalty.. because in woke Revolution the point is never “the thing” itself but always the Revolution .. the point is always to raise consciousness towards the Revolution.
we are now “saved” from this “gross error” … i.e… The Guidance From the Holy Ghost was always a Fable …
Francis was a messianic prophet.. now we have Leo his appointed .. “attitudes must change”.
(No.. Catholics must obey the Church and the Office of Peter.. what we have had is one.. & now two popes who undermine and are an enemy to that Office.)
p.s. this is way above my pay grade. and I’m stupid.. but I’m not that stupid.
“You will be hanged by the neck until dead.” The injection execution was fixed… but not by the murdered victim.
The death penalty is the temporal punishment for taking innocent life out of God’s hands.
Atheists believe that there is no life after death. So do Francis and Leo.
To answer Mr. Wixter’s complaints, let’s craft an appeals process which takes eight years, max and four years on average and lets put malefactors in front of firing squads. Somehow I don’t think he’d be pleased with either situation.
The part that has always gotten me about the push to abolish the death penalty is this part of the Catechism: “More effective systems of detention have been developed, which ensure the due protection of citizens” I’m not even sure what that means. It’s like they just said it because they just said it. Consider the violence within prisons if nothing else. What is it talking about? It comes off like they want to do this and are grasping for reasons to justify the change.
To anyone who knows anything about prisons Dave it comes off a simple lie. In my county on July 22, 1978 we had a massive prison riot in the course of which three guards were murdered by inmates, Lt. William Thomas, Stanley Cole, and Robert Conkle, and three others severely injured. Most prisons are highly unsafe and do little to rehabilitate the hardened criminals among the incarcerated. Having the Catechism engage in gaslighting for political ends is disheartening.
Forget the death penalty, a pretty substantial chunk of the left doesn’t even want murderers incarcerated! And if you don’t believe me, just ask the adoring throngs of Lindsay Clancy and Luigi Mangione.
Stupid argument.
You might as well argue against the death penalty *because* Francois forgot to maintain the ropes on the guillotine. Argue, instead, about Francois!
Tennessee was a competence issue, but libs use it as a doorway to attack the concept of the death penalty.
The United States Constitution guarantees equal Justice for all, that would be the murder victim and the murderer.
Equal Justice makes the death penalty constitutional.
Considering that the death penalty is executed through the power of attorney of the condemned murderer and that the murderer brings himself to Justice through his citizenship in the state and the human race and that human dignity does not end with death and that Jesus Christ, Himself recommended the millstone about the neck in the depths of the sea eliminating capital punishment severely truncates equal Justice for all.
at the risk of being annoying, it was never about the death penalty.
(but about choosing a low hanging fruit to establish the revolution in people’s minds…)
-and as we pretty much all can see, that revolution is well under way.o
Pope Francis even spoke against life imprisonment. Are they trying to get rid of early consequences for crime as an analogy that there are no eternal consequences either?
The English writer, Samuel Johnson a devout High Church Anglican, had some comments on capital punishment that are as true now as in the 18th century.. As far as quick and efficient is concerned, the Chinese method is difficult to improve upon. I suppose the use of experienced physicians who practice euthanasia could also be considered.
I don’t think Pope Francis’s statement can be considered binding on Catholics where the ordinary magisterium had already recognized the licitness of the death penalty in certain circumstances. He wasn’t speaking from the Chair of Peter nor in collaboration with a universal council.
a cleric is to be concerned with saving souls… “do not fear those who kill the body but cannot kill the soul”
a person knowing going to their death can prepare.. a criminal can repent… for the hardened criminal having committed heinous crimes dying in their sleep unrepentant is an eternal sentence.
this was never about the death penalty.
Genesis 9:6. Period.
LQC, Thanks for printing the piece from Matt Walsh.
VOTE NO VIRGINIA!, for Amendments 1 and 2. If they pass Yes, living aborted babies will be left to die.
Regarding the killing of abortion survivors: I’m not sure how the pro-birthright citizenship and anti-death penalty crowd can justify executing American citizens without any due process.
Ben Franklin said: “We have a Constitutional Republic if we can keep it.”
Without Constitutional equal Justice for all, we have lost it.
Abortion is genocide. Doctors who murder human beings without consequences is not Constitutional equal Justice for all.
Pope Francis even spoke against life imprisonment. Are they trying to get rid of early consequences for crime as an analogy that there are no eternal consequences either?
==
Tom McKenna called that about 15 years ago. You eliminate capital sentences, they’ll attack life-without-parole. You eliminate that, they’ll attack mandatory minimums. The objection is to punishment.
==
The vanguard of the Democratic Party has been explicit about this of late. The ACLU and characters like Jerome Miller were explicit about it 35 years ago. (The difference being that Miller was against incarceration tout court and today’s Democrats favor it for political dissenters and various other deplorables).
Sadly, we can thank St John Paul II for a lot of this. Although he didn’t try to change doctrine, the way he went about opposing it as a matter of policy paved the way for what we are seeing now.
The First Things link is a pay wall or sign in.
Here’s the full article from EWTN’s website
https://www.ewtn.com/catholicism/library/catholicism–capital-punishment-2637