Robert E. Lee’s Greatest Victory

Sunday, July 16, AD 2017

 

He was a foe without hate; a friend without treachery; a soldier without cruelty; a victor without oppression; and a victim without murmuring. He was a public officer without vices; a private citizen without wrong; a neighbor without reproach; a Christian without hypocrisy and a man without guile. He was a Caesar without his ambition; Frederick without his tyranny; Napoleon without his selfishness; and Washington without his reward.

Benjamin H. Hill on Robert E. Lee

 

 

“It’s a warm spring Sunday at Saint Paul’s Episcopal Church in Richmond. As the minister is about to present Holy Communion, a tall well-dressed black man sitting in the section reserved for African Americans unexpectedly advances to the communion rail; unexpectedly because this has never happened here before.

The congregation freezes. Those who have been ready to go forward and kneel at the communion rail remain fixed in their pews. The minister stands in his place stunned and motionless. The black man slowly lowers his body, kneeling at the communion rail.

After what seems an interminable amount of time, an older white man rises. His hair snowy white, head up, and eyes proud, he walks quietly up the isle to the chancel rail.

So with silent dignity and self-possession, the white man kneels down to take communion along the same rail with the black man.

Lee has said that he has rejoiced that slavery is dead. But this action indicates that those were not idle words meant to placate a Northern audience. Here among his people, he leads wordlessly through example. The other communicants slowly move forward to the altar with a mixture of reluctance and fear, hope and awkward expectation. In the end, America would defy the cruel chain of history besetting nations torn apart by Civil War.”

From “April 1865:  the Month that Saved America

Continue reading...

5 Responses to Robert E. Lee’s Greatest Victory

  • Bai Macfarlane would like to send a press release. Can you e-mail an address to ma.defending@marydasovocates.org

  • I have long admired Robert E. Lee, a just and humble man. May he rest in peace.

  • Here is a countering view, that points out that Lee’s contemporaries saw Lee’s actions as a challenge to equality, and Lee never said anything to disabuse them of this view.
    http://www.civilwarmonitor.com/blog/fantasizing-lee-as-a-civil-rights-pioneer
    Does anyone have more evidence pertaining to his actions that day? I personally wish the modern positive view were true, but…

  • Attempting to mind read Lee a century and a half later Tom is a futile exercise. What we do know is what he did. I would note that Lee lent his support to a successful movement to raise funds to provide public education for the children of former slaves in Virginia, and that as President of Washington College he would repeatedly expel students who engaged in attacks on blacks. Like all of us Lee was a child of his time and place. Unlike many of us he showed an ability to transcend his time and place to some degree when it came to race.

  • Nice story. Now let us leave that church that Church and walk to the town square and bring our hammers down on the statue of Robert E. Lee.

Leave a Reply

Robert E. Lee And Our Contemporary Political Battles

Monday, June 5, AD 2017

He was a foe without hate; a friend without treachery; a soldier without cruelty; a victor without oppression; and a victim without murmuring. He was a public officer without vices; a private citizen without wrong; a neighbor without reproach; a Christian without hypocrisy and a man without guile. He was a Caesar without his ambition; Frederick without his tyranny; Napoleon without his selfishness; and Washington without his reward.

Benjamin Hill on Robert E. Lee

 

 

My how General Robert E. Lee still raises passions..  Adam Serwer has a one sided attack on Lee in The Atlantic, which reeks of presentism and displays little understanding of Lee or his times Go here to read it.  Dan McLaughin gives a half-hearted defense of Lee at National Review Online.  (Did all boldness die at National Review with Buckley?)  Go here to read it.  As Lincoln’s biggest fan on the internet, my views on Lee are well known to faithful readers of this blog:

 

Great Americans fought on both sides of the Civil War, and one of the greatest of Americans, of his time or any time, was Robert E. Lee.

Continue reading...

16 Responses to Robert E. Lee And Our Contemporary Political Battles

  • The problem with the eradication of the Civil War memorials is that it’s impossible not to see this as one stage in an ongoing trend; an ongoing agenda. Anyone who thinks it will stop there and not end up at the limits of D.C. has to be beyond blind.

    There’s also this uncomfortable notion that race is the irremediable sin. That if we can in any way pin the racist label on a person, we can then condemn the person as nothing but a racist, refuse any mercy, and use the condemnation to dismiss or eliminate any contributions of that person. This is an excellent summary of what I’m seeing:

    “The Left constantly digs through long-forgotten personal histories in seeking to discredit people; to them, you will forever be whatever the worst interpretation of the worst thing you have ever done or said is. That this is patently absurd, of course, is irrelevant to them. They care nothing for the truth, they only seek to destroy. They are little satans, accusers in service to the Great Accuser.”

    There’s truth to this if you think about it.

  • “There’s also this uncomfortable notion that race is the irremediable sin.”

    And the complete obsession of the left in this country. White leftists tend to be as race obsessed as a Klansman circa 1866.

  • Something I just learned: June 5 Confederate soldiers, sailors and marines in the Civil War were made U.S. Veterans by an act of Congress in 1957: U.S. Public Law 85-425 Sec. 410; Approved 23 May 1958.

    This made all Confederate Army, Navy and Marine Veterans equal to U.S. Veterans. Additionally, under U.S. Public Law 810, approved by the 17th Congress on 26 February, 1929, the War Department was directed to erect headstones and recognize Confederate grave sites as U.S. Grave sites.

  • THANK YOU Mary DeVoe for that information – it should be pondered by those who take down statues and landmarks.

  • and some of those white lefties were Klansmen, e.g. late Sen Robert Byrd, (D)WV. Lots of amnesia on the Left.

  • (Did all boldness die at National Review with Buckley?)

    I think the replacement of John O’Sullivan with Richard Lowry was the watershed. The economy of opinion journalism is lousy and there are not many careers to be made in it. I cannot help but notice that Jonah Goldberg is just about the only engaging producer of topical commentary that emerged from the ranks of the starboard magazine press as we knew it in 1994. Ross Douthat, Megan McArdle, Michelle Malkin, Glenn Reynolds, David Burge, &c were never employed by any such venues. George Will and Charles Krauthammer were. The people Lowry has hired over the years produce workmanlike but bland material, or they produce insipid dreck, or they produce material that seems calculated to abrade much of National Review‘s readership.

  • “There’s also this uncomfortable notion that race is the irremediable sin.”
    Race is an act of “the Laws of Nature and Nature’s God” from THE UNANIMOUS DECLARATION OF INDEPENDENCE, ratified by every state. Prejudice against man is hatred of God and the imposition of atheism. So, too is same sex attraction an act of “the Laws of Nature and Nature’s God”. It is the free will act of man to become addicted to lust and practice sodomy, a free will act detrimental to the salvation of the sodomite’s soul and salvation.

  • Very sad that in his own Commonwealth of Virginia, at this moment, Charlottesville is pulling down his statue and re-naming the park that bears his name. This talibanic effort to purge our history will likely continue. It’s a deeply ignorant movement, particularly with regard to Lee and Virginia, since our state rejected secession when the issue was Lincoln’s election and the perceived threat to slavery laws. Only when Lincoln ordered up troops for a southern invasion, and only then, did Virginia secede, convinced that this was an unconstitutional act by the federal government. One wonders if a different approach by Lincoln, at least with regard to states like Virginia, might have produced a different outcome. If Virginia had not seceded, the confederacy would have never survived beyond a year or two.

  • If he had done nothing else, America would owe him an unpayable debt for not scattering the Army of Northern Virginia to the hills in April 1865 to engage in guerilla warfare. But he did “plenty else,” too. Purging his memorials (and those of the Confederate soldiery) says more about us than it does about him (and them).

  • And it will not stop with Confederates. The slave holding Founding Fathers are a natural next target. Eisenhower and the men of the Great Crusade, as he called it, served in a racially segregated Army. Eventually they will go after Obama because he came late to the cause of gay marriage. The hilarious things about this is that the portside of our politics has a real problem with sponsoring political violence, raging intolerance of intellectual diversity, and often a romantic view of murderous leftists like Che Guevara. We have them spending their time attempting to censor the historical record while ignoring the glaring beams in their own eyes.

  • And what a small percentage of black Americans who owned slaves? When it comes to slavery there is plenty of blame to go around.

  • There’s also this uncomfortable notion that race is the irremediable sin.

    Or at least terrorism.

  • Mr. McClarey, the activists who pushed for the recent removal of
    the various Confederate memorials down in New Orleans also
    lobbied successfully to have that city’s George Washington
    Elementary School change its name, because President Washington
    had owned slaves. And yes, they’ve already indicated that they will
    not rest until the statue of Andrew Jackson comes down and Jackson
    Square Park is renamed, Battle of New Orleans notwithstanding…

    So yes, as you say, it will not stop with Confederates.

  • In Charlottesville, the writing is on the wall… first Lee and Jackson, but how long will the city be able to ignore the odious presence of the college founded, designed, and built by that arch-racist and slaveholder, Thomas Jefferson? I hope it happens soon, so I can watch the Left eat their own, as UVA is a hotbed of radical Leftism, and also the city’s main economic support.

  • For what it is worth: For better answers: check out Prager University’s five minute clip: The Inconvenient Truth About the Democratic Party by Carol Swain, professor of political science at Vanderbilt University.

Palm Sunday 151 Years Ago

Sunday, March 20, AD 2016

 

 

It is poor business measuring the mouldered ramparts and counting the silent guns, marking the deserted battlefields and decorating the grassy graves, unless we can learn from it some nobler lesson than to destroy.  Men write of this, as of other wars, as if the only thing necessary to be impressed upon the rising generation were the virtue of physical courage and contempt of death.  It seems to me that is the last thing we need to teach;  for since the days of John Smith in Virginia and the men of the Mayflower in Massachusetts, no generation of Americans has shown any lack of it.  From Louisburg to Petersburg-a hundred and twenty years, the full span of four generations-they have stood to their guns and been shot down in greater comparative numbers than any other race on earth.  In the war of secession there was not a State, not a county, probably not a town, between the great lakes and the gulf, that was not represented on fields where all that men could do with powder and steel was done and valor exhibited at its highest pitch…There is not the slightest necessity for lauding American bravery or impressing it upon American youth.  But there is the gravest necessity for teaching them respect for law, and reverence for human life, and regard for the rights of their fellow country-men, and all that is significant in the history of our country…These are simple lessons, yet they are not taught in a day, and some who we call educated go through life without mastering them at all.

Rossiter Johnson, Campfire and Battlefield, 1884

 

 

 

I have always thought it appropriate that the national nightmare we call the Civil War ended during Holy Week 1865.  Two remarkably decent men, Robert E. Lee and Ulysses S. Grant, began the process of healing so desperately needed for America on Palm Sunday, April 9, 1865 at Appomattox.  We take their decency for granted, but it is the exception and not the rule for the aftermath of civil wars in history.  The usual course would have been unremitting vengeance by the victors, and sullen rage by the defeated, perhaps eventually breaking out in guerilla war.  The end of the Civil War could so very easily have been the beginning of a cycle of unending war between north and south.  Instead, both Grant and Lee acted to make certain as far as they could that the fratricidal war that had just concluded would not be repeated.  All Americans owe those two men a large debt for their actions at Appomattox.

Grant in his memoirs wrote, “When Lee and I separated he went back to his lines and I returned to the house of Mr. McLean. Here the officers of both armies came in great numbers, and seemed to enjoy the meeting as much as though they had been friends separated for a long time while fighting battles under the same flag.”

Lee so appreciated the generosity of the terms of surrender given by Grant, that for the remainder of his life he would never allow a word of denigration about Grant to be spoken in his presence.

Continue reading...

3 Responses to Palm Sunday 151 Years Ago

  • Interesting find, Don… so this method of vivid documentary story-telling did not originate with Ken Burns, as I sometimes hear.

    Haven’t watched it all yet, but so far, pretty balanced presentation, with a slight bent in the direction of the victors! Even Vallandigham gets a mention, the Democrat congressman who amazingly was imprisoned for giving speeches critical of the war and of Lincoln, whom he called “King Lincoln.”

    Definitely love seeing Hal Holbrook at Appomattox, just an hour down the road from my house.

  • “Haven’t watched it all yet, but so far, pretty balanced presentation, with a slight bent in the direction of the victors! Even Vallandigham gets a mention, the Democrat congressman who amazingly was imprisoned for giving speeches critical of the war and of Lincoln, whom he called “King Lincoln.””
    Vallandigham was ultimately exiled to the Confederacy. He made his way back into the Union through Canada, after seeking money from Confederate representatives in Canada to buy weapons to set up a Northwest Confederacy, with Lincoln turning a blind eye to his reappearance. He was the moving force behind the peace plank of the Democrat platform in 1864 and was listed by the Democrats as Secretary of War in a McClellan administration. After McClellan repudiated the peace plank Vallandigham withdrew for a time in campaigning for him.

    Vallandigham had a shadowy relationship with the undercover Southern spy group, the Knights of the Golden Circle, later renamed the American Knights. He testified at the trial of several of them in April 1865. While denying that he had joined that organization, he admitted to talking with representatives of the Confederacy in Canada.

    His death in 1871 is a caution to all defense attorneys:

    “Vallandigham died in 1871 in Lebanon, Ohio, at the age of 50, after accidentally shooting himself in the abdomen with a pistol. He was representing a defendant (Thomas McGehan)[citation needed] in a murder case for killing a man in a barroom brawl at the Golden Lamb Inn. Vallandigham attempted to prove the victim, Tom Myers, had in fact accidentally shot himself while drawing his pistol from a pocket while rising from a kneeling position. As Vallandigham conferred with fellow defense attorneys in his hotel room at the Golden Lamb, he showed them how he would demonstrate this to the jury. Selecting a pistol he believed to be unloaded, he put it in his pocket and enacted the events as they might have happened, snagging the loaded gun on his clothing and unintentionally causing it to discharge into his belly. Although he was fatally wounded, Vallandigham’s demonstration proved his point, and the defendant, Thomas McGehan, was acquitted and released from custody (to be shot to death four years later in his saloon).”

  • Oddly coincidental, I just received this post, also dated Palm Sunday.
    ..http://vaflaggers.blogspot.com/2016/03/va-flaggers-re-lee-statue-in.html
    .
    Fascinating stuff on Vallandigham too, Mr. Mac.

February 25, 1865: Lee Will Not Give Up the Texas Brigade

Wednesday, February 25, AD 2015

 

..”Attention Texas Brigade” was rung upon the morning air, by Gen. Gregg, “the eyes of General Lee are upon you, forward, march.” Scarce had we moved a step, when Gen. Lee, in front of the whole command, raised himself in his stirrups, uncovered his grey hairs, and with an earnest, yet anxious voice, exclaimed above the din and confusion of the hour, “Texans always move them.”
…never before in my lifetime or since, did I ever witness such a scene as was enacted when Lee pronounced these words, with the appealing look that he gave. A yell rent the air that must have been heard for miles around, and but few eyes in that old brigade of veterans and heroes of many a bloody field was undimmed by honest, heart-felt tears. Leonard Gee, a courier to Gen. Gregg, and riding  by my side, with tears coursing down his cheeks and yells issuing from his throat exclaimed, “I would charge hell itself for that old man.”

 

Private Robert Campell, 5th Texas Infantry

The fighting erupted early on the second day of the Battle of the Wilderness.  Grant assumed that Hill’s corps had been fought out on the first day and could be overrun with a strong attack.  At 5:00 AM Hancock attacked with three divisions, with two in support.  By 6:00 AM Hill’s corps was in full retreat and disaster loomed for Lee.  At that time the 800 man Texas Brigade, perhaps the elite fighting unit in the Army of Northern Virginia, the vanguard of Longstreet’s corps arrived and saved the day.  Longstreet launched a two division counterattack up the Orange Plank Road, with the Texans, who suffered 650 casualties, leading the attack on the north side of the Road.

This action by the Texan Brigade, and similar actions on many other fields, caused Lee to treasure the unit as his shock troops.  This caused Lee to deny a request by the Governor of Texas in February of 1865.  The request and the denial are contained in this letter from Jefferson Davis to the Governor of  Texas:

Continue reading...

2 Responses to February 25, 1865: Lee Will Not Give Up the Texas Brigade

May 10, 1863: Let Us Pass Over the River and Rest Under the Shade of the Trees

Friday, May 10, AD 2013

“I have but to show him my design, and I know that if it can be done it will be done.  Straight as the needle to the pole he advances to the execution of my purpose.”

Robert E. Lee on Stonewall Jackson

Of Thomas Jonathan Jackson, nicknamed Stonewall by General Barnard Bee at the battle of Bull Run, it was said he lived by the New Testament and fought by the Old.  Certainly throughout his life he was a convinced Christian.  As a young man he would attend services of various Christian denominations.  In Mexico, during his service in the Mexican War, he attended mass, although sadly he did not convert to Catholicism.  Instead he eventually became a Presbyterian.  His Bible was his constant companion, and he would often speak of God and theological matters in private conversation.

Jackson in his professional life was a soldier.  Just before the Civil War he was a professor of natural and experimental philosophy (science) and artillery instruction at the Virginia Military Institute.  As a teacher he made a good soldier.  His lectures were rather dry.  If his students seemed to fail to grasp a lecture, he would repeat it the next day, word for word.

His home life was a mixture of sorrow and joy.  His first wife died in childbirth along with their still-born son, a tragedy that would have crushed many a man less iron-willed than  Jackson.  His second marriage, like his first, was happy, but heartache also haunted it.  A daughter died shortly after birth in 1858.  A second daughter was born in 1862, Julia, shortly before Jackson’s own death in 1863.  His wife would spend a widowhood of 52 years, dedicated to raising their daughter, cherishing the memory of her husband, and helping destitute Confederate veterans.  For her good works she became known as the Widow of the Confederacy.  Their daughter Julia would marry and have children before her early death of typhoid fever at age 26.  Her two children had several children and there are many living descendants of Jackson.

He and his second wife established and taught a Sunday school for black slaves.  At the time it was against the law in Virginia to teach slaves to read, but apparently that is precisely what Jackson and his wife did.   One of the last letters he ever posted was his regular contribution he mailed off throughout the war for the financial support of the Sunday school for slaves he and his wife had founded.

Continue reading...

One Response to May 10, 1863: Let Us Pass Over the River and Rest Under the Shade of the Trees

  • my father died on the same day but in 2003 -140 years later. he trend to me in his hospital bed and said “Not long now, the Lord will come for me” he was in the Presence of Christ 75 minutes later.
    he was also stoical like Stonewall Jackson

May 2, 1863: Jackson Flanks Hooker

Thursday, May 2, AD 2013

  When the blue-coated
Unprepared ranks of Howard saw that storm,
Heralded by wild rabbits and frightened deer,
Burst on them yelling, out of the whispering woods,
They could not face it.  Some men died where they stood,
The storm passed over the rest.  It was Jackson’s storm,
It was his old trick of war, for the last time played.
He must have known it.  He loosed it and drove it on,
Hearing the long yell shake like an Indian cry
Through the dense black oaks, the clumps of second-growth pine,
And the red flags reel ahead through the underbrush.

Stephen Vincent Benet, John Brown’s Body

 

The plan having been made for the flank attack against Hooker, it remained for Jackson to execute it.  For a very long day he and his corps marched along the front of Hooker’s massive army’s front and into the rear of the right of his army.  Numerous reports came to Hooker from Union units reporting movement by a large number of Confederates to their front.  Hooker, now firmly ensconced in the pleasant land of wishful thinking, chose to interpret these reports as evidence that Lee was retreating.  Hooker had his army sit idle that day, the day when he could have crushed Lee with overwhelming numbers.

Chancellorsville_May2

Lee described Jackson’s march in his official report of the battle on September 21, 1863:

Continue reading...

5 Responses to May 2, 1863: Jackson Flanks Hooker

  • You seem very interested in the Civil War. Perhaps you could give me a few tutorials? Hahaha! I have an exam on it on the 14th – my final exam at University which is pivotal if I am to graduate with a good mark. Please pray for me! God bless.

  • Ah, Hooker: the Peter Principle in action.

  • J: “Come, Holy Spirit, and fill the hearts of Thy faithful. Enkindle in them the fire of Thy love. Send forth Thy Spirit and they shall be created. And, renew the face of the Earth. Amen.”

    Just saying: Where were the Union cavalry? J.E.B. Stuart’s cav had brilliantly screened Jackson’s flank march. Union infantry taunt to cav: “I never saw a dead cavalryman.” That changed at Gettysburg, where Stuart was missing until too late and the Union cav beat his on the third day.

    Jackson’s troops were such hard marchers they were called “foot cavalry.” They habitually covered many miles and went into action.

    And, were there no pickets out from XI Corps?

    “In the Chancellorsville Campaign, the Irish Brigade helped round up the XI Corps fugitives after Stonewall Jackson’s famous flank attack. On May 3, it marched from Scott’s Mills to near the Chancellor House to support the 5th Maine Battery, dragging off its guns when the gunners were rendered ‘hors de combat.’”

May 1, 1863: Lee and Jackson Plan a Military Masterpiece

Wednesday, May 1, AD 2013

Chancellorsville May 1, 1863

On the evening of May 1, 1863, General Robert E. Lee knew several facts about the military situation confronting him:

1. His army was between two forces, Hooker with approximately 70,000 men at Chancellorsville and Sedgwick south of Fredericksburg with approximately 40,000 men.  Confronting Sedgwick he had Early with about 11,000 men and confronting Hooker Lee had around 40,000 men.

2.  If Sedgwick and Hooker attacked aggressively Lee’s army could be destroyed between them.

3.  Neither Sedgwick nor Hooker had demonstrated much appetite for attack.  Hooker had launched a brief attack the morning of May 1, but had quickly called it off, Hooker being content to defend against Lee.

4.  Lee now had the initiative, ceded to him miraculously by the man who commanded a combined force more than twice the size of Lee’s.

5.  What to do with the initiative was the question.  How could Lee overcome such a grave disparity in numbers?

Continue reading...

Palm Sunday One Hundred and Forty-Eight Years Ago

Sunday, March 24, AD 2013

I have always thought it appropriate that the national nightmare we call the Civil War ended during Holy Week 1865.  Two remarkably decent men, Robert E. Lee and Ulysses S. Grant, began the process of healing so desperately needed for America on Palm Sunday, April 9, 1865 at Appomattox.  We take their decency for granted, but it is the exception and not the rule for the aftermath of civil wars in history.  The usual course would have been unremitting vengeance by the victors, and sullen rage by the defeated, perhaps eventually breaking out in guerilla war.  The end of the Civil War could so very easily have been the beginning of a cycle of unending war between north and south.  Instead, both Grant and Lee acted to make certain as far as they could that the fratricidal war that had just concluded would not be repeated.  All Americans owe those two men a large debt for their actions at Appomattox.

Continue reading...

6 Responses to Palm Sunday One Hundred and Forty-Eight Years Ago

  • Mr. McClarey. You are doing them justice by trimming the tree that they planted so many years ago. Thank you!

  • Don McClarey: You ain’t so bad yourself!

    May God grant you and your family with a Holy, Blessed Easter.

    Karl J Wengenroth

  • Thank you Karl. A blessed Holy Week and Easter to you and yours!

  • Thank you for this wonderful information.

    As we all see things through our own personal lenses, and as a different “civil” contention goes on this current holy weeK, in our Supreme Court, my hope that we could be as great and good as those generals and soldiers.

    This statement of U. S. Grant spoke aloud to me: “I knew there was no use to urge him to do anything against his ideas of what was right.”

    This week the Supreme Court talks about marriage on a national level. I hope they can be great enough to carefully discern and good enough do what is right.

  • The end of the war would quite possibly have even gone better if President Lincoln had not been shot. Lincoln’s overriding agenda with the ceasefire was to be far more magnanimous in victory than President Johnson was to prove to be. Whether that would have worked out in reality (as opposed to theory) better of course we will never know. But even with what we got, it could have gone a lot worse if not for the basic decencies of Lee and Grant in the conclusion of hostilities between the two sides.

Robert E. Lee, the Beatles and the Internet

Saturday, October 8, AD 2011

They do not know what they say. If it came to a conflict of arms, the war will last at least four years. Northern politicians will not appreciate the determination and pluck of the South, and Southern politicians do not appreciate the numbers, resources, and patient perseverance of the North. Both sides forget that we are all Americans. I foresee that our country will pass through a terrible ordeal, a necessary expiation, perhaps, for our national sins.

Robert E. Lee

Something for the weekend.  Further evidence of what a wild and wacky place the internet truly is!  Quotations from Robert E. Lee teamed up with the Beatles song Let it Be.  I was surprised at how much I enjoyed the video, although for share emotional impact, and a nice recreation of what Lee meant to the ragged, indomitable troops in the Army of Northern Virginia, nothing can top this scene from Gettysburg:

Continue reading...