Thursday, March 28, AD 2024 1:50pm

Dune the Nightmare

 

Well, Clan McClarey, as is our custom, will be toasting the new year by watching Dune (1984), a film so spectacularly bad that is entertaining, a true train wreck of the filmmaking art.  Director David Lynch in the above video explains just how much a disaster the three years the film took to make became for him.  In a 1985 interview, below, he is, unsurprisingly, somewhat more circumspect, although he seems haunted by the ordeal he has just put behind him.

 

 

0 0 votes
Article Rating
13 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Pinky
Pinky
Thursday, December 31, AD 2015 12:54pm

– and yet, if I had to rewatch any of the three David Lynch movies I’ve seen (Eraserhead, Mulholland Drive, and this one), it’d be Dune.

– Am I imagining it, or did he damn Kyle MacLachlan with oblique praise? He said that they were looking for certain qualities and never found them – that statement could be the result of editing, though. He also said that everyone else on the set was impressed by him.

– Just seeing those clips reminds me of a description of Lord Voldemort: he did great things. Terrible, but great.

DJH
DJH
Thursday, December 31, AD 2015 2:24pm

Don’tknow too much about Dune, but we’re there two different film versions? Is this the one with Sting?

Pinky
Pinky
Thursday, December 31, AD 2015 3:14pm

John Hurt doesn’t so much steal that scene as the whole scene steals the movie, maybe the entire series of movies. Everything that happens after that point is just tying up loose ends.

The Bear
Thursday, December 31, AD 2015 5:16pm

It was atmospheric, and many individual scenes were effective. It was also ridiculously over-the-top. Who on earth thought David Lynch would be the right man to adapt someone else’s work? The Bear likes everything Lynch has done, from Straight Story to Inland Empire (Eraserhead, not so much.) But he’s got to be doing his own thing, where he can add rabbits living a dull existence in a dingy apartment if he wants to.

DJH
DJH
Thursday, December 31, AD 2015 6:32pm

Mr. McClarey: my sister also liked the movie. Likened it to a train wreck, so bad it was good. Best wishes for the New Year.

Greg Mockeridge
Greg Mockeridge
Thursday, December 31, AD 2015 8:18pm

Just goes to show the best doesn’t always have to be good!

TomD
TomD
Friday, January 1, AD 2016 12:48am

Pinky, watch The Elephant Man. It is one of the few films in recent decades that makes use of overt Christian imagery.

Clay
Clay
Friday, January 1, AD 2016 10:24am

Dune (in all of its incarnations) has long been a favorite of mine. For the David Lynch one, the Judas Booth version, which adds nearly an hour, is a personal favorite.

Interestingly enough, the mountain ranges south of Juarez, where many of external desert scenes were filmed, look strangely familiar.

For those who have not read any of the expanded Dune universe by Frank Herbert’s son, Brian Herbert, I highly recommend them. There is a literal ton of back story to the overall saga.

Christine
Christine
Saturday, January 2, AD 2016 2:37am

Any thoughts on the new SYFY miniseries of Childhood’s End by Arthur C Clarke? I just saw the first episode- The Overlords. Seems more timely than ever!.

Discover more from The American Catholic

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading

Scroll to Top