Jupiter and Jollity
Published Saturday, March 14, 2009 A.D. | By Donald R. McClarey
Something for the weekend. Gustav Holst’s Jupiter, the bringer of jollity, my favorite part of The Planets. Some things become so popular that we tend to take them for granted. I am afraid that is what has happened to some degree with The Planets. It is a magnificent piece of music and places Holst in the top ten list of composers of all time in my estimation.
10 Responses to Jupiter and Jollity
Subscribe by eMail
Recent Posts
- The Last of the Light Brigade
- Terri Schiavo Is Still Unavailable for Comment
- New Republic as State Organ
- Competing Religions
- Governor Dale
- Ben Carson’s National Prayer Breakfast Speech
- The New York Times as State Organ
- Lent in a Sinless Age
- Why it is Worth Worrying: On the Brink of a New Pontificate
- We Must Not Forget
- At Last Night’s Emergency SCHISM Meeting…
- Lincoln and the Will of God
Recent Comments
- k c Thomas commented on The New York Times as State Organ
(5 hours ago) - philip commented on What Wondrous Love Is This?
(7 hours ago) - Kim Buda commented on Ben Carson's National Prayer Breakfast Speech
(7 hours ago) - T. Shaw commented on New Republic as State Organ
(9 hours ago) - Jon commented on What Wondrous Love Is This?
(10 hours ago) - Pinky commented on New Republic as State Organ
(1 days ago) - Bill Sr. commented on Ben Carson's National Prayer Breakfast Speech
(1 days ago) - Pinky commented on New Republic as State Organ
(1 days ago) - Templar commented on The Last of the Light Brigade
(1 days ago) - Templar commented on The Last of the Light Brigade
(1 days ago) - Dale Price commented on Competing Religions
(1 days ago) - Pinky commented on New Republic as State Organ
(1 days ago)
Archives
- February 2013 (50)
- January 2013 (77)
- December 2012 (89)
- November 2012 (99)
- October 2012 (133)
- September 2012 (115)
- August 2012 (87)
- July 2012 (78)
- June 2012 (99)
- May 2012 (99)
- April 2012 (99)
- March 2012 (107)
- February 2012 (113)
- January 2012 (102)
- December 2011 (85)
- November 2011 (81)
- October 2011 (82)
- September 2011 (80)
- August 2011 (78)
- July 2011 (65)
- June 2011 (83)
- May 2011 (94)
- April 2011 (84)
- March 2011 (98)
- February 2011 (87)
- January 2011 (90)
- December 2010 (91)
- November 2010 (106)
- October 2010 (102)
- September 2010 (101)
- August 2010 (89)
- July 2010 (106)
- June 2010 (136)
- May 2010 (112)
- April 2010 (131)
- March 2010 (55)
- February 2010 (98)
- January 2010 (114)
- December 2009 (105)
- November 2009 (123)
- October 2009 (102)
- September 2009 (116)
- August 2009 (110)
- July 2009 (109)
- June 2009 (102)
- May 2009 (46)
- April 2009 (126)
- March 2009 (104)
- February 2009 (90)
- January 2009 (87)
- December 2008 (76)
- November 2008 (126)
- October 2008 (103)
Catholic and Infertile
Catholic Arts & Beauty
Catholic Bible Links
Catholic Blogroll
- A Catholic Mom in Hawaii
- Against The Grain
- An Examined Life
- and sometimes tea
- Biblical Evidence for Cthlcsm
- Bonfire of the Vanities
- Cahiers Péguy
- Catholatarian
- Catholic Light
- Catholic Phoenix
- Catholic Translations
- Coffee and Canticles
- Conversion Diary
- CVSTOS FIDEI
- Disputations
- Fidelity to the Word
- Head Noises
- la nouvelle théologie
- Mary Meets Dolly
- Over the Rhine and into the Tiber
- Per Christum
- Pro Ecclesia
- Riparians at the Gate
- Sacramentum Vitae
- SoCon or Bust
- The Catholic Comedy
- The Catholic Key Blog
- The Divine Life
- The Minor Premise
- This Cross I Embrace
- Video Meliora
- Vivificat!
- Whosoever Desires
Catholic Economics Links
Catholic Education/Schools
Catholic Environmental Links
Catholic Evangelizing
Catholic Film & TV Production
Catholic Forums
Catholic Health Care Links
Catholic Humor
Catholic Law Links
Catholic Liturgical Links
Catholic Men Links
Catholic Music
Catholic Mysticism
Catholic New Media
Catholic Newpapers
Catholic News Links
Catholic Orthodox Links
Catholic Political Links
Catholic Pro-Family Links
Catholic Pro-Life Links
Catholic Pro-Marriage Links
Catholic Punditry
- American Papist
- Catholatarian
- Catholic and Enjoying It!
- Catholic Fire
- Creative Minority Report
- Crisis Magazine
- CVSTOS FIDEI
- Damian Thompson
- DarwinCatholic
- Dyspeptic Mutterings
- Father John Zuhlsdorf
- George Weigel
- Journeys in Alterity
- Lair of the Catholic Cavemen
- National Catholic Register
- Opinionated Catholic
- Pro Ecclesia
- RealCatholicTV.com
- Standing on My Head
- Ten Reasons
- The Catholic Thing
- The Pertinacious Papist
- Thoughts of a Regular Guy
Catholic Radio
Catholic Religious Orders
Catholic Resources
- African-American Outreach
- Biblical Evidence for Catholicism
- Black Catholic History
- Byzantine Cthlc Church (US)
- Catechism (CCC)
- Catholic Encyclopedia
- Catholic Hierarchy
- Catholic Latin Mass
- Catholic Leadership Institute
- Catholic Search Engine
- Catholic Theology Resources
- Catholic Translations
- Compendium of the CCC
- Early Christian Writings
- flockNote
- Mass Times
- National Cthlc AIDS Network
- Natl Black Cthlc Congress
- Natural Procreative Tchnlgy
- Papal Encyclicals
- Pope Benedict XVI Fan Club
- Pope John Paul II Writings
- QuoteCatholic
- Sancta Missa
- Sonitus Sanctus
- Universalis
- USCCB
- Vatican: English Site
- Vatican: Latin Site
Catholic Social Justice Links
Catholic SSA Links
Catholic TV Links
Catholic Women Links
Catholic Young Adult
Catholic Youth Links
Orthodox Blogroll
Other Christian Blogs
Other Christian Resources
Other Christian Websites
Secular Websites
- Advocates for Homeschooling – HSLDA
- Almost Chosen People
- American Cancer Society
- American Conservative
- American Education Reform
- American Life League
- American Red Cross
- Americans for Fair Tax
- Americans United for Life
- Amrcn Conservative Union
- Amrcn Health Care Reform
- Apostolate of Roman Catholic Homeschoolers – A.R.C.H.
- Asian Conservatives
- Athens and Jerusalem
- Autism Society of America
- Big Government
- Big Hollywood
- Black Genocide
- Blue Dog Democrats
- Breast Cancer Prevention Inst
- Breitbart
- C-SPAN
- Care Net Pro Life Clinics
- Citizens for Term Limits
- Coaltn on Abort/Brst Cncr
- Concerned Women/America
- Conservatives/Patients Rts
- Consistent Life
- Defend Marriage
- Dem Congrsnl Campaign Cte
- Dem Lgsltv Campaign Cte
- Dem Senatrl Campaign Cmte
- Democratic Gov Assoc
- Democratic Ldrshp Council
- Democratic Natl Convention
- Democratic Party
- Democrats for Life
- Dems for Education Reform
- Economic Policy Institute
- Energy Independence Now
- Face AIDS
- Fair Economy
- Faithful Democrats
- Fathers for Good
- Fathers for Life
- Feminists for Life
- GayPatriot
- Go Green Initiative
- GOProud
- Health Care/Homeless
- House Democrats
- Invisible Children
- Latino Partnership for Conservative Principles
- Make Poverty History
- Mediaite
- Mercy Corps
- Murder Vctms Fams/Rcncltn
- National Black Pro Life Union
- National Right to Life
- National Right to Work
- Natl Rep Cngrssnl Cte
- Natl Rep Senatorial Cmte
- NC/Abolish Death Penalty
- NewsBusters
- Nurses for Life
- Pave the Way Foundation
- PeaceCorps
- Physicians for Life
- Politico
- Poverty.com
- Pro-Life America
- Project 21
- Project Vote Smart
- Pure Love Club
- Raging Elephants
- RealClearBooks
- RealClearMarkets
- RealClearPolitics
- RealClearWorld
- reason.tv
- Redeem The Vote
- Rep State Leadership Cmte
- Repub for Envmntl Protec…
- Republican Gov Assoc
- Republican Jewish Coalition
- Republican Ldshp Cncl
- Republican Natl Convention
- Republican Party
- Repubs for Single Payer
- Ross Douthat
- Save Darfur
- SBA List
- Senate Democrats
- Stand Firm
- Stop Human Trafficking
- Suggest Ideas
- Suicide Prevention
- The Art of Manliness
- The Buck Stops Here
- The Daily Caller
- The Medievalist
- The Other McCain
- The Polycarp Research Inst.
- The White House
- US House of Representatives
- US Senate
- What’s Wrong With the World
- Women in Congress
Tag Cloud
Abortion
Abraham Lincoln
American Civil War
American History
Anti-Catholicism
Barack Obama
Big Government
Catholic Chaplains
Catholic Church
Catholicism
Catholic Social Teaching
Christianity
Conservatism
Culture of Death
Culture of Life
Economics
Election 2010
Election 2012
Gay Marriage
Health Care Reform
HHS Mandate
History
Humor
Islam
Jesus Christ
Liberalism
Marriage
Mitt Romney
Music Video
Nancy Pelosi
Obama Administration
ObamaCare
Planned Parenthood
Politics
Pope Benedict XVI
Pope John Paul II
Pope Leo XIII
President Barack Obama
Pro-Abortion
Pro-Life
Republican Party
Rick Santorum
Sarah Palin
U.S. Constitution
World War II
Our Visitors. . .
Bach, Handel, Mozart, Beethoven, Schubert, Brahms, Schumann, Dvorak, Bruckner, Tchaikovsky,and Mahler are clearly above Holst.
That’s saying nothing about Shostakovich, Elgar, Wagner, Rossini, Verdi, Grieg, Sibelius, Rachmoninov and many others.
Personal taste Mr. DeFrancisis. Arguing the relative worth of musical compositions, especially when the music being compared is of a high order, is as fruitless as trying to determine which actor has given the best performance of Hamlet over the centuries.
Cows have taste.
I’d say there are objective criteria here– albeit, elusive ones.
Mars is better than Jupiter.
That’s why it is the Quatermass theme.
Actually Mr. DeFrancisis I once had the task of picking best cow in show at a county fair. There were criteria to use in judging, but once all but the three best cows in show had been eliminated I felt choosing the best one was a fairly subjective process on my part, since all three of the cows were prime specimens. The owner of the winning cow disagreed with me and thought the process by which I chose her cow was completely objective. The owners of the other two cows did think the process had been subjective and were quite ready to share with me their subjective opinions of the quality of the decision I had made.
I’m not sure I’ll “go there” on whether Holst is a ‘top ten’ composer, though without question I really enjoy The Planets, but just to keep the apple of discord rolling I’ll note that I read a while back that Holst actually got really tired of The Planets’ popularity, thinking it wasn’t his best work.
Whether he was right on this I can’t judge, because the only Holst music I have is The Planets. So from his point of view, I’m clearly part of the problem.
I am just contented that my old record player and my newer, yet apparently becoming more obsolete by the day, CD player, are willing to accept and play a variety of types of music, especially classical music, which has moved to near the top oof my favorites.
My favorite will always remain good old Rock and Roll from the 50s-early 60s and Buddy Holly will always be my most hallowed musician, although Mozart is right behind him. In my advancing years I have come to better appreciate a wider variety of musical styles.
Now I will have to listen to the various planet, pieces, to see if I have a preference. Most likely I will simply enjoy them, all, as they play.
Thanks for this post.
I love this piece of music, I failed to mention.
Thanks for the post.
Deciding which is better, Mars or Jupiter, is a rather apples to oranges comparison..
“Mine’s the SUN. I like it because it’s like the King of Planets!”
Ah…the Planets. Great music, played it in high school. Though I think Saturn and Mercury are underrated pieces.
Congrats, Don. What you lack in taste when it comes to presidents you make up for in music.