Tuesday, March 19, AD 2024 5:20am

The Stakes Are Small

This is an indirect response to a post over at Thoughts of a Regular Guy entitled ‘Turncoats in the Culture War’.

It is a cliche in academia that the disputes are vicious because the stakes are small. I think this is a useful saying to keep in mind for bloggers as well.

One benefit of the internet is that it allows people who would not otherwise meet to discuss and debate topics of common interest. It is easy to forget, however, that relatively few people frequently traffic political blogs (still less, Catholic political blogs), or are even moderately politically informed. Furthermore, the people who do traffic blogs tend to already have strong opinions about politics/religion/culture, and so are the least likely to be persuaded on an issue of significance. The influence of any one blogger (or team of bloggers) is fairly limited.

I say all of this not, of course, to argue that blogging is pointless; just that it is not as important as the tenor of some of our conversations would suggest. It is easy in practice to confuse two very different things: 1) the importance of the issue being discussed; 2) the importance of a given conversation about that issue. What this suggests to me is that blogging is a recreational activity which should be of service in some small way to others and to the Church.

It is not a forum to say the type of uncharitable things one cannot say in face-to-face conversations, nor a place to vent, still less a place to carry on extended grudge matches with perceived ideological opponents. I have certainly been guilty of all of these behaviors at various points. However, as far as I can recall, the only times I have actually changed my mind about an issue in response to a blog post, the writer made a well-reasoned case that took counter-claims seriously, rather than focusing on polemics or personal attacks. I doubt my experience is atypical. This is a long way of saying three things: 1) Strong personal denunciations are generally unpersuasive, uncharitable, and unnecessary (alliteration!); 2) It is better to focus on the merits of arguments rather than the people making them; 3) The following cartoon proves that a picture is more valuable than three hundred and sixty-two words:

duty_calls

0 0 votes
Article Rating
7 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Gerard E.
Gerard E.
Monday, December 1, AD 2008 7:47am

In other words, play nice in the sandbox, boys and girls.

Ryan Harkins
Monday, December 1, AD 2008 8:29am

As a note, that xkcd comic tickled me pink the first time I read it, and it continues to do so. I haven’t spent as much time frequenting forums or discussion groups as I could have, but I have seen such a plethora of bad arguments that often my fingers twitch in an autonomic urge to respond. Of course, that doesn’t prevent my arguments from being bad themselves, but there is certainly an, “Aaaaahhhh! That person is dead wrong! The universe will come to a halt if I don’t rebut him!”

crankycon
Admin
Monday, December 1, AD 2008 9:43am

but there is certainly an, “Aaaaahhhh! That person is dead wrong! The universe will come to a halt if I don’t rebut him!”

Right on! I think I have gotten myself into more trouble hastily interjecting myself into a discussion because I have seen someone making what I deem to be a bad faith argument – not just wrong, but wrong and full of strawmen argument. I have tried more and more to let trollish comments pass, but it’s a battle.

That said, I do think that we can distinguish between ad hominen argumentation and strongly worded arguments. I think that Paul’s post falls more squarely into the latter category.

DarwinCatholic
Monday, December 1, AD 2008 11:36am

It does seem awfully easy in the blogsphere for quarrels to take on a family argument like quality, in which all slights are remembered as if they were yesterday and only unconditional surrender is acceptable.

jonathanjones02
jonathanjones02
Monday, December 1, AD 2008 2:12pm

Darwin,

I agree entirely.

Discover more from The American Catholic

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading

Scroll to Top